The Shakespeare Conference: SHK 12.0279 Tuesday, 6 February 2001
From: Peter T. Hadorn <
Date: Monday, 05 Feb 2001 10:19:06 -0600
Subject: Hamlet and the Passage of Time
I have a question regarding the passage of time in "Hamlet" that someone
might be able to help me with: How much time has passed between Acts 1
and 2? A related question, how long has Hamlet's father been dead?
In 1.2.137, Hamlet says of his father: "But two months dead--nay, not so
much, not two. . . ." Soon it will become "within a month" as Hamlet
telescopes time. Which is correct? I've always assumed the first time,
and then, as Hamlet gets more passionate about remembering his dead
father, the passage of time becomes/seems less to him (reminds me of the
Player King's advice to PQ). [But now, as I think about it, it could be
that as Hamlet is thinking about it, he realizes that his father has
been dead less than a month, but that it SEEMED longer to him at first.
Yikes!]. So, in other words, Hamlet Sr. has been dead two months [or
one month] in Act 1.
Then in Act 3.2.124ff, there is this exchange:
Ham.: For look you how cheerfully my mother looks and my father died
within's two hours.
Oph.: Nay, 'tis twice two months, my lord.
This suggests that Hamlet Sr. has been dead four months and that the
break between Acts 1 and 2 is two months [or three months].
But almost immediately, Hamlet cuts the time in half when he says: "O
heavens, die two months ago and not forgotten yet!"
So now I'm confused [and I'm sure I've confused the readers of this
message]. Is this another unsolvable "Hamlet" mystery?
I have consulted the Norton Shakespeare, the Riverside, the Arden (1982
ed) and the Bedford. Only the Arden comments on the passage of time.
Checking the variants among Q1, Q2, and F I find no help to this puzzle.
Any ideas out there? Thank you.
English, University of Wisconsin-Platteville