The Shakespeare Conference: SHK 12.2094 Monday, 2 September 2001
From: Richard Burt <
Date: Sunday, 2 Sep 2001 08:25:33 -0400
Subject: LA Times Article Defending the Teaching of (Shakespeare) Porn
Porn Is Part of Our Culture
By RICHARD BURT,
Richard Burt, a professor of English at the University of Massachusetts
in Amherst, is the author of "Unspeakable ShakesXXXpeares" (St. Martin's
Over the past few weeks, newspapers and television shows have widely
reported that college students are hot for porn courses on campus.
Whether these reports are accurate or just misleading exaggerations,
they do raise a serious question: Why should pornography be studied in
an academic setting?
Cultural conservatives and their low-brow counterparts--talk-show
hosts--believe porn is not a fit topic for the classroom. They would
have us believe that porn is simply videos of people having sex, and
hence trivial and the source of nothing more significant than classroom
Right-wing feminists maintain that porn degrades and oppresses women,
and that while women appear to be enjoying sex in porn, they are really
being raped. In either case, the attack on porn studies is actually less
an attack on the study of sex than it is on the study of popular
culture. The conservatives who bemoan the study of porn are the same
people who oppose the study of film and popular culture in general.
If they had their way, students would be limited to reading from a
"great books" curriculum designed in the 1930s. It would consist of a
very narrow list of works written almost exclusively by white men, with
a few token women and African Americans added to feign diversity.
But this is nothing more than a dream of returning to a past that never
existed anyway. The study of art and literature has always involved
attending to both elite and popular forms and genres.
Conservatives can't close the door on popular culture, for how can we
study Shakespeare without studying Shakespeare on film? How can we
understand Shakespeare's reverberation in our culture without examining
his appearance in popular media like TV sitcoms, advertisements, films
like "Porky's 2" and, dare I say it, even hard-core pornographic films
like "A Midsummer Night's Cream"?
If Shakespeare appears in a large number of hard-core pornographic
adaptations, how can we understand Shakespeare's afterlives if we don't
also study them?
Also, pornography changes. Porn in 2001 looks very different from porn
produced in 1968, which in turn looks very different from porn made in
1928. Therefore, porn, like all other mass-produced elements of popular
culture, has a very great deal to say about our society and the cultural
dynamics that structure it.
Once it becomes clear that we have to study popular culture as well as
elite culture, the conservatives lose, and so they "lose it" in frothing
How can we properly study popular culture without studying pornography,
the most popular of all genres, the one on which Americans spend an
estimated $14 billion a year?
By now, with the expansion of the porn market into suburban homes thanks
to the Internet, the VCR and the recent reporting on porn in the
mainstream media, enough people have seen porn for themselves to know
just how clueless the right-wing feminist critique of porn really is.
The politics of pornography are complex, by no means reducible to a
simplistic and sexist opposition between evil male oppressors and
innocent, vulnerable female victims.
The question is, are we really free to do and say what we want? The
numerous women who go into the porn industry to appear in the 10,000 or
more porn videos and films made each year obviously do so by choice. And
students who elect to take classes on porn, or that include porn, do so
There is perhaps one thing about which we really have no choice. If we
are serious about wanting to understand our culture, then we perforce
have to study porn, we have to think about it.
S H A K S P E R: The Global Shakespeare Discussion List
Hardy M. Cook,
The S H A K S P E R Webpage <http://ws.bowiestate.edu>
DISCLAIMER: Although SHAKSPER is a moderated discussion list, the
opinions expressed on it are the sole property of the poster, and the
editor assumes no responsibility for them.