The Shakespeare Conference: SHK 17.0265 Monday, 3 April 2006
From: Steve Urkowitz <
Date: Sunday, 02 Apr 2006 11:54:40 -0400
Michael B. Luskin asks:
>I am still interested in opinions as to why Hotspur is so hostile and
>unpleasant to his co rebels. He comes close to braking his alliances
>with them, and they certainly becomes less interested n their joint
>military efforts. Why does he deal with them so?
This is the kind of question that I think actors have to ask (or should
ask) and that I think directors are obligated to invent answers for. My
own directorial style leads me to look for parallels in literary and
personal narratives that make sense out of Hotspur's actions and
attitudes. I grew up in the Bronx, and a fair number of guys I knew
were just this contentious, even with "friends" in the neighborhood.
It's a kind of testosterone challenge, "picking" fights as a matter of
principal and reflexive practice. Belligerence seems to be one of the
qualities of macho or "doric" societies that Shakespeare was
particularly sensitive to. He weaves its nasty presence into heroes and
villains. Homer gives Odysseus this same kind of explosive anger at a
possible insult when he's among the Phaiaikhians, the people who are
going to bring him home to Ithika. Don Quixote has similar moments when
he feels that his honor or his ideas are being opposed, and he'll act
with absurd rage.
The alternative to such hostility -- the road of containment of anger,
and of maintaining a continuing discourse in the face of discord --
becomes a hallmark of maturity in many heroic narratives.
Shakespeare carries on a career-long critique of machismo, nevertheless
recognizing its social and psychological power and attraction. It's not
that he's simply hostile to the warrior code. Rather he recognizes it
as a kind of common aspect of culture that men and women have to
negotiate, as inevitable as dealing with gravity or time.
Of course, I'm arguing for a kind of essentialism. Ah, well. In the
Bronx, that's what we had to work with, and that's what Shakespeare
seems to have found in his sources to build into his portrayals of
characters in Rome and Greece and Italy and France and England. Alas,
I've found that same Hotspur in college administrators and colleagues
and cousins. But (I think) along with Shakespeare, I've also found the
wonders of amity and laughter and voluntary peaceful negotiation in the
graceful magic of theatrical collaboration. Maybe Shakespeare draws
Hotspur to show exactly how attractive such a guy can be even while he
sets himself up for disaster.
Separate note: If anyone on the list is near Perpignan in the south of
France this week, you can see my production of A Midsummer Night's Dream
at the University of Perpignan on Thursday and Friday, April 6 & 7 at
12:30pm and again on Friday April 7 at 9pm. In English with lively,
Visiting Professor, Erasmus Mundus Program, Perpignan
S H A K S P E R: The Global Shakespeare Discussion List
Hardy M. Cook,
The S H A K S P E R Web Site <http://www.shaksper.net>
DISCLAIMER: Although SHAKSPER is a moderated discussion list, the
opinions expressed on it are the sole property of the poster, and the
editor assumes no responsibility for them.