The Shakespeare Conference: SHK 20.0619 Friday, 18 December 2009
From: Hardy M. Cook <
Date: Friday, December 18, 2009
Subject: I'm PUZZLED
I am concerned about the recent spate of puzzle / riddle / hidden
meaning postings on the list.
Since I am pledged to striving to distribute posts that are of interest
to the academic Shakespeare community, I am going to call for a slowing
down if not stopping of postings about anagrams / puzzles / riddles /
ciphers / codes / and other hidden meanings.
Many, if not most, of these messages are based on the belief that the
authorial presence behind the plays/poems was fond of embedding hidden
messages in them. This proposition has not to my satisfaction been
demonstrated. Now, puns -- language play -- that is another matter. I
accept without reservation that, let's called the author Shakespeare,
Shakespeare was fond, as many Early Moderns were, of punning, of playing
with language. But I cannot accept that Shakespeare was "addicted" to
including puzzles or ciphers throughout his writing.
On a more speculative realm, it appears to me that the desire to find
puzzles could be closely related to the desire to attribute the works to
someone other than William Shakespeare of Stratford-upon-Avon based upon
the finding of hidden messages in the texts by the adepts. Both of these
approaches are from my point of view wish fulfillment pursuits.
Agamemnon opens Act One, scene three, of _Troilus and Cressida_ saying,
What greefe hath set the Iaundies on your cheekes?
The ample proposition that hope makes
In all designes, begun on earth below
Fayles in the promist largenesse: checkes and disasters
Grow in the veines of actions highest rear'd.
As knots by the conflux of meeting sap,
Infect the sound Pine, and diuerts his Graine
Tortiue and erant from his course of growth.
"The ample proposition that hope makes / In all designes."
To me, finding puzzles in Shakespeare is a proposition that is made by
hope. The puzzles are there often because the seeker wishes/hopes to
find them there. The initiates, adepts, masters, magi, maguses, seerers,
sorcerers, vaticinators, prognosticators, and magisters uncover the
hidden knowledge and having divined the hidden meanings or the secret
author are now prepared to share their discoveries with us.
I am sorry if I am coming across too harshly here (actually, much of
what I am writing is an exercise in Rhetoric), but I too, as all of us
are, am on a quest, at least as long as I am breathing, and I am
concerned about discerning what is genuine from what is not. And I have
found myself, even as I regularly visit a healer, skeptical of
conspiracies and of "I-know-something-you-don't-know" thinking.
I freely confess that I am expressing my prejudices. You may agree with
me or you may argue with me, but I am the gatekeeper for the list and I
would like to slow down or eliminate all together most postings about
puzzles, riddles, ciphers, and so on at least for the time being.
Hardy M .Cook, Ph.D.
Editor of SHAKSPER
S H A K S P E R: The Global Shakespeare Discussion List
Hardy M. Cook,
The S H A K S P E R Web Site <http://www.shaksper.net>
DISCLAIMER: Although SHAKSPER is a moderated discussion list, the
opinions expressed on it are the sole property of the poster, and the
editor assumes no responsibility for them.