The Shakespeare Conference: SHK 22.0026 Thursday, 27 January 2011
From: Charles Weinstein <
Date: January 22, 2011 9:24:50 AM EST
Subject: Not Prince Hamlet, Nor Meant to Be
National Theatre Live: Hamlet starring Rory Kinnear, directed by Nicholas Hytner
Horatio loves Hamlet; he may even want to be Hamlet. But wishes are not horses, and it makes no sense to
cast a born Horatio as Hamlet. Rory Kinnear is a thirtyish, balding plodder with all the charisma of a
substitute teacher. He is not unintelligent: he has considered his lines, and he conveys their meaning
clearly if not trippingly. (He has even come up with a new reading: "Soft! You, now! The fair Ophelia!").
But he has no charm, no brilliance, minimal wit and limited powers of invention and variation. In brief,
he is ordinary. Ophelia tells us that Hamlet is the undisputed Star of Elsinore, and even Claudius admits
that the common people adore him. These accolades sit uneasily upon Kinnear, who turns _The Tragedy of
Hamlet, Prince of Denmark_ into "The Secret Life of Walter Mitty."
Nicholas Hytner has surrounded him with minimalist scenery and a few familiar concepts. For the second
time in a year, we see Denmark as a 21st-century police state. Hytner has replaced Gregory Doran's
surveillance cameras with a bevy of Secret Service men, but the idea is the same and entirely wrong, for
as a police state Denmark is ridiculous. The "dangerously mad" Hamlet puts on an unvetted play attacking
second marriages before the newly-remarried Queen. He runs riot during the performance with obscenities,
jeers and threats. He nearly kills the unguarded King at his prayers but decides to wait. Instead, he
visits the Queen in her room where he promptly kills Polonius. Doran and Hytner wanted to convey the
oppressive omnipresence of Big Brother, but what we see are the serial pratfalls of Keystone Kops.
Matters are not helped by their depiction of the Chief Spymaster. When Peter Hall first directed Hamlet
(1965), he reconceived Polonius as a cunning politician using the mask of befuddlement to accomplish his
ends. Kenneth Branagh did much the same in his 1996 film. Unaccountably, Doran and Hytner opt for a
traditional comic dullard, further dispelling the Orwellian ambience. At least Doran's Polonius was
funny. In contrast, David Calder loses laugh after laugh through bad timing and off-kilter rhythyms. (He
does the same as the Gravedigger in Act V). I have happy memories of Calder's fantastical, dream-struck
Falstaff, but that was fifteen years ago.
In truth, Hamlet will not bear too much updating. If you choose, like Hytner, to present Ophelia as a
thoroughly modern young woman -- sexy, feisty, jousting with her strange anachronism of a brother -- you
raise the question of why she yields so quickly to Polonius' silly edicts. Why does her liberated mind
give way before the mundane pressures of a bad love-affair and an aging father's death? Sensing these
discrepancies, Hytner suggests that Ophelia does not drown under the weight of her own distraction, but
is instead murdered by the royal goons. This doesn't help, and Ruth Negga is too pedestrian an actress to
make sense of the muddle.
On the plus side of the ledger, Patrick Malahide is a refreshingly slimy Claudius, a serpent in the
orchard indeed. (Some actors try to ennoble the character. Nonsense: the man murders his brother and
marries his sister-in-law for gain, and then engineers the murder of his stepson). Clare Higgins fleshes
out the underwritten Gertrude in both senses, showing us a once-beautiful woman whom years and alcohol
have thickened into a harsh, unlovely middle-age. Her gratitude to Claudius is keen, but her resentment
at the passage of time is greater.
Among the ensemble, Matthew Barker impresses as the Norwegian Captain (a small part, but there are no
small parts), while Ferdinand Kingsley, son of Ben, is an efficient, yuppified Rosencrantz. Giles Terera
looks like Eddie Murphy and plays Horatio about as well as Murphy could. The tearful Alex Lanipekun shows
us Laertes the sentimentalist but not Laertes the fanatic avenger. James Laurenson was an embarrassing
Gaveston to Ian McKellen's Edward II (1970); as the Ghost and the Player King, he seems to have finally
ripened into competence.
"Hamlet without the Prince" has become a metaphor; unhappily, Kinnear and Hytner literalize it. In
Doran's production, we saw Hamlet as Harlequin. This was shallow, but more diverting than Hamlet as
Prufrock. One has seen worse -- one has seen Beale -- but one has also seen much better.
S H A K S P E R: The Global Shakespeare Discussion List
Hardy M. Cook,
The S H A K S P E R Web Site <http://www.shaksper.net>
DISCLAIMER: Although SHAKSPER is a moderated discussion list, the opinions expressed on it are the sole
property of the poster, and the editor assumes no responsibility for them.