The Shakespeare Conference: SHK 17.1083 Saturday, 9 December 2006
From: Hardy M. Cook <
Date: Saturday, December 09, 2006
Subject: SHAKSPER RoundTable Revisited
This morning as an excuse to stay in bed for a while, I began to rethink
my proposal for initiating a new feature to SHAKSPER, roundtable
discussions. Below are my thoughts. I will consider responses and
private e-mails to me and report back any significant results.
Focused Topic: Each topic will be of current academic interest to the
discipline of Shakespeare or Early Modern Studies
Guest Moderator: A Guest Moderator (GM) will responsible for initiating,
moderating, directing, and concluding the discussions.
Reading List: A Reading List of three to five items suggested by the
Guest Moderator will be available on the SHAKSPER server for a limited
time as if they were set aside in a reserved collection in a library.
The readings will be announced at least two weeks before discussion
begins and anyone participating will be expected to be thoroughly
familiar with them.
Digest of RoundTable Postings: Once a week, on Tuesdays, a digest of
RoundTable postings (clearly identified as such to distinguish it from
daily SHAKSPER discussions) will be distributed to the membership. The
Guest Moderator will initiate the discussions with, for example, a
question and will organize and comment on the week's submissions before
suggesting the direction that discussions should follow the subsequent
week. I, of course, will handle all of the technical aspects of
forwarding contributions to the GM, of formatting the GM's digest, and
of distributing it to the membership. The Guest Moderator will
determine, announce, and conclude discussion of the topic. The final
digest in a RoundTable thread will be the Guest Moderator's summary
statement. After an interim, another RoundTable will begin.
Other Features: The Guest Moderator's summary and, a list of links to
the various digests in each RoundTable thread, to enable future readers
to follow the discussions as they evolved, will be available in a
separate section of the SHAKSPER server.
Call for Discussion (CFD): Ideally, I would like anyone interesting in
moderating a RoundTable to submit to me a Call for Discussion.
Prospective moderators should provide a paragraph about themselves and
interest in the topic. I believe that moderating a RoundTable could be
an important adjunct to one's current research interests. Prospective
moderators should send me a topic/title, a limited reading list, and a
description of the proposed scope of the discussion.
Final Thoughts: The idea of these RoundTables is to provide a forum for
members to use the Internet in such a manner as to enable academic
discourse in an alternative platform to conferences, journals, and such.
Thus, RoundTable discussions will be conducted on a more formal level
than ordinary list discussions: contributors will be expected to reflect
upon their offerings for before submitting them and to be knowledgeable
of the subject under discussion.
Comments: All will regard all responses as private correspondence with
me and will report back as necessary. It is highly possible that members
will consider this a good idea but be unwilling to make a commitment to
a new enterprise without knowing how much time or effort will be
involved. I completely understand. But the idea intrigues me, and I just
needed to field it one more time.
FYI: I made the initial suggestion for SHAKSPER RoundTable discussions
in July; I then posted two follow-ups with refinements about how I
envisioned the Forum to work and a long-list of possible topics:
http://www.shaksper.net/archives/2006/0628.html In this last post, I
asked for anyone who might be interested to submit to me a 300 to 500
word proposal or call for discussion (CFD), suggesting possible areas of
discussion and a question or statement to be used to initiate discussion
for our first RoundTable, but I got no responses. Below are possible
topics that have been suggested:
* Historicism, New Historicism, Presentism: Where we are and where we
* Performance Criticism: Thirty Years After
* SHAKESPEARE'S LIVES to 1599: The Future of Shakespeare Biography
* Electronic Shakespeares
* New Uses for Old Books
* Pedagogy: The Shakespeare Classroom Today
* Alternative to the Research Paper in the Shakespeare Classroom
* Realization of Text into Performance.
* Editorial practices
* Shakespearean (Early Modern) printing and publishing
* Textual matters
* The relevance of religion
* Restoration and 18th- & 19th-century adaptations and interpretations
* Shakespeare on film
* Shakespeare's language
* Family life in Shakespeare and his time
* Historical approaches (e.g., related to law, politics, finance, etc.).
* TV Shakespeare
* Current Shakespeare Film Adaptations
S H A K S P E R: The Global Shakespeare Discussion List
Hardy M. Cook,
The S H A K S P E R Web Site <http://www.shaksper.net>
DISCLAIMER: Although SHAKSPER is a moderated discussion list, the
opinions expressed on it are the sole property of the poster, and the
editor assumes no responsibility for them.