The Shakespeare Conference: SHK 18.0313  Thursday, 3 May 2007

From: 		Sean B. Palmer <This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.>
Date: 		Saturday, April 21, 2007 7:13 AM
Subject: 	A Savage Mystery

I recently purchased a book by Richard Savage, secretary and librarian of 
Shakespeare's Birthplace circa 1910, that contains a mysterious 
inscription that perhaps someone can help me with.

The book in question is garrulously entitled /Shakespearean Extracts from 
Edward Pudsey's Booke Temp Q. Elizabeth & K. James I/, and is a 
transcription, with comments, of a commonplace manuscript by Pudsey 
containing quotes from several Elizajacobean plays. The quotes include 
some from an /Irus/ which Savage believed to be a lost Shakespeare play, 
but which I have found is Chapman's /Blind Beggar of Alexandria/.

The inscription that puzzles me is a handwritten pencil note on the inside 
cover of my own copy, a copy which, I should add, has most of its pages 
still bound together uncut as though it has just come from the publisher 
and never been read:

"Mr W. Jaggard.
with the kind regards of
Richard Savage
26 May 1910."

The book cost me 5, and when I got it I noticed the inscription and 
thought "oh that's nice, a signed copy", but didn't think much about it. 
I've just been writing up some notes on Hamlet, and I got this book out to 
consult it; it can still be read with care by opening up the pages from 
the bottom carefully and peering in-I certainly don't wish to destroy the 
fusing. Since the front cover had fallen off (by the time it reached me), 
the inside cover is now the outside cover so the inscription is prominent, 
though quite faded.

Given that I was in research mode, I figured I might as well look up the 
details of the inscription, and it was only then that I noticed it was 
addressed to *W. Jaggard*, a rather obviously famous name with respect to 
Shakespeare. I've searched for later Jaggards, but found none contemporary 
with Savage, so that leads me to ponder a few possibilities:

* Savage had a friend called W. Jaggard by marvellous coincidence, and I 
haven't yet been able to track down the details of the man.

* Savage was writing an odd and slightly ritualistically tinted dedication 
to the publisher of so many of Shakespeare's works.

* It was some kind of other joke by Savage the meat of which is now lost.

* It's a later inscription, possibly a forgery.

The gentleman from whom I purchased the book, having found it for sale on 
the internet, seemed entirely unconcerned with the nature of the book 
itself and as I've already mentioned was selling it for an extremely 
agreeable price. He mentioned that it was from the collection of his late 
father, a collection which he was now selling off piece by piece. Since he 
didn't hike the price up, I can't for one moment admit the possibility 
that he forged it for monetary gain. Now that I look back at the records 
of the transaction I find that he *did* actually tell me about the 
dedication, but I hadn't noticed; and funnily enough, he transcribed the 
faded "Mr W." as "Dr W.", with the looped entry to the "M" looking like a 
lowercase "d", I suppose.

So if not a forgery by the seller, or his father, perhaps the person who 
sold it to his father? But even if it is a forgery, it's a forgery that 
doesn't really make all that much sense. If you're going to forge a 
dedication in a work, you'd surely pick a name at random that sounds right 
for the time rather than a name which is essentially a conundrum?

So those are the facts as far as I have them. Can anyone add anything in 
the way of further conjecture or research that might settle the matter?

Sean B. Palmer, http://inamidst.com/sbp/

S H A K S P E R: The Global Shakespeare Discussion List
Hardy M. Cook, This email address is being protected from spambots. You need JavaScript enabled to view it.
The S H A K S P E R Web Site <http://www.shaksper.net>

DISCLAIMER: Although SHAKSPER is a moderated discussion list, the opinions 
expressed on it are the sole property of the poster, and the editor 
assumes no responsibility for them.

Subscribe to Our Feeds


Make a Gift to SHAKSPER

Consider making a gift to support SHAKSPER.